miwahni (miwahni) wrote,

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Reviewing the reviews.

Sometimes the reviews are more entertaining than the story - following are just a sampling of reviews for The Fandom Writer by Nickolaus Pacione. All original spelling left intact.

This story would have had a lot of potential, with a great plot idea. The sad thing is, it sucked.
So true.

You need a good, not to mention forgiving and masochistic, editor to help you along the rough patches. And from what I've read, the entire story is a rough patch.
True again.

I am not critizing this stories writing. You have a very good writing style, but you are intollorant. You are prejudice. 60 jews died because of prejudice. But I am by no means comparing you to Hitler... Don't get upset because you get "flamed" (you get criticized, there's a difference), you just flamed all the writers of an entire genre. It's always funny when the reviewer's spelling etc is worse than the author's. And doncha just love it when someone brings Hitler into the discussion?
And...60 jews? What happened to the rest of them, then?

Here's my review: this was terrible. Learn to spell first, then learn how to write. Hope that helps!
Truer than the truest true thing in truedom.

You now what you need? A good ass-fuck. Nothing will change a homphobe's mind about the "bastradization' of art than a good stick up the ol' man tube. Migth even teach you some humility seeing as how we're convinced we're the next Poe (yeah I could perfectly see you characterizing yourself as "Albert Poe" there egotistical queeth.)to be on the recieving end.And how about you actually learn to write half way decently before harping about your narrow minded views? Geez, I hope I'm not such a crappy writer when I'm 28.

  • So, you're working from home?

    I've been reading all this advice - get up at your normal time and use your usual commute time to read a book; get dressed into your normal work…

  • 12 - weekly roundup

    Sad news about Peter Capaldi leaving Dr Who - I liked his 12, far better than Matt Smith's 11. I hope that his replacement is as good; let's start a…

  • (no subject)

    I've been sitting here listening to this odd noise for a while, one of those that you can't quite place, and you're not entirely sure where it's…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded